Super Long Blog Alert!
I’ve been journaling a lot lately about the deep-down liberating rage that I’ve mentioned several times on my blog. I’ve also been asked to explain more about how anger can be a positive thing. [If you're interested in reading further on this topic, here's an article about Positive Anger and another about the Benefits of Anger.]
This morning as I was trying to think how to frame it all in a way that not only made sense but that answered all the various aspects of the issue that could be raised, especially in light of the book Terri and I are reading by Eckhart Tolle entitled A New Earth: Awakening to Your Life’s Purpose, I realized that there’s no way to keep this blog relatively short and succinct and handle the entire issue. I tried, but failed.
Firstly, there are several concepts still prevalent in Western thinking that are traditional and widely assumed, but that are false. A couple of examples: the noble savage (aka primitivism) and the newborn being a tabula rasa. Two false assumptions that are important to this issue are: the existence of spirit (ie, any metaphysical, supernatural entities, analogous to the soul and/or God) and the accompanying idea that these ‘spiritual entities’ hold peace and happiness as their highest aim…. or alternatively, that peace and/or happiness are more ‘spiritual,’ more noble, more salvific, more superior, than other emotional states.
[It is beyond the scope of this blog to explain all the arguments into
why the spiritual or supernatural entities cannot exist. You can read
more on this topic at The Secular Web Library and in Richard Dawkin's The God Delusion.]
Now, I have nothing against inner peace or happiness. I spent years searching for either (or both) and finally found some degree of them for myself, in no small part thanks to many of the sorts of teachings contained in books similar to Tolle’s, many of which Oprah has championed over the years, in addition to the wide and varied readings I’ve done in religion, philosophy, mythology, psychology, science, and more. Compared to my inner life of 10 years ago, I’m the downright epitome of inner peace. Compared to back then, I could be the gosh-darned poster child for inner peace and happiness.
And certainly, inner peace and happiness are more pleasant, usually, than the so-called ‘negative’ emotions, such as sadness, envy, anger, jealousy, and the like. So, they are better in that they are more pleasant for a human to experience. But they are not better in any sort of cosmic way, in and of themselves. We do not win any brownie points (or points towards salvation) in this our indifferent, non-conscious universe because we find inner peace, happiness, or because we achieve enlightenment…or “Awareness” (Tolle’s term for these things). If someone achieves these things, hurray! Enjoy them. Wallow in the pleasantness of them. But don’t think they mean anything.
When Tolle speaks of our awareness of ourselves as being more true, or our true selves, (and Oprah often uses this expression as well), I want to know how it is they believe that ‘awareness’ is any more true than the parts of me that they point out as false, such as my life story and circumstances, or my hand, or my feelings. It is, in reality, no more than my mind being aware of itself thinking, but it is still my mind, the functioning of my brain, the gray matter within my skull. To be aware of one’s self and to recognize that the baggage of the past, the worries of the future, and the labels we put on our surrounding are artificial constructs to some degree, and to realize that we have control over our physical and emotional reactions to life in the present moment… these are all good things. These are good insights to have. These are enlightenment.
But I am still also my memories, my feelings, my body, my hungers, my decisions, and everything else that makes up my physical existence. Because, in reality, all we truly have IS a physical existence. That ‘Awareness’ in your mind which feels like an escape from physicality…is merely another physical process. All states of consciousness (and unconsciousness, btw) are, by necessity, physical processes. So to say that that ‘awareness’ (the so-called spiritual experience) is true and everything else (ie, the physical) is false, is nonsensical.
Ok, maybe that was a tangent, but it’s also relavent. Because part of the implication in the question “How is anger positive?” is that not only is anger negative and better avoided, but that it leads away from the nobler goals of peace and happiness to which we should aspire for the sake of our spirit… for the betterment of our spirit… or because it is more ‘spiritual’ to do so.
The same people who would have you believe that also hold Jesus up as a teacher of peace. Without going into a long diatribe about how much bologna that is, I’ll simply give you a few examples of how even Jesus got angry.
For one, he cursed a helpless, innocent fig tree for not bearing fruit out of season. That’s not exactly rational.
For another, he had a hissy-fit in the temple and overturned all the money-changer’s tables. Certainly it was his anger in that incident that led him to make his point.
Finally, many times he became irritated and griped at the apostles for being stupid and short-sighted (often because they couldn’t understand the nonsensical parables that he usually refused to explain).
So, even Jesus got angry and used that energy to further his cause. I won’t even begin to list all the angry things God does in the OT. That’s a book in and of itself. (In fact, that’s the OT!)
I see this has become an extremely long blog today, and if you’re as tired of reading it as I am of writing it, you’ll be happy to know that just now, in this moment, a very true and peaceful and happy me, myself, and I have all three decided to continue it tomorrow. Until then…. peace.